Cheap Whiskies
Today me and a couple of my friends had the final tasting in the "30 Euro project". During the last year I have bought several bottles of whisky that are below 30 euros, to prove that there is quality there as well.
We have done 2 tastings to decide what the itinerary was going to be for the finals. During the 2 'semi finals' the favorites were chosen based on the quality, the taste and the nose of it. Of course, this was all very subjective and based upon our opinions. My closest whisky friends tend to like the Islay whiskies the most, but another dude in my "circle of trust" is more the Speyside kind of guy, which makes it just a bit more interesting.
The whiskies we tasted today were:
- Auchentoshan 10
- Tobermory 10
- The Arran 10
- Scapa 14
- Laphroaig 10
- Smokehead
I have some other's but they didn't make it, or it was just too much of the same type. A 10 year old Bruichladdich from Auld Edinburgh didn't make it because we wanted to satisfy the non-Islay drinkers as well.
The reports were as follows. (warning. notes below are written by a novice whisky taster, with little experience. I could be way off :-) )
Auchentoshan 10:
Very smooth, but tasty enough to be noticed. The triple distilling makes it a bit softer as a regular Scotch but nice nonetheless.
The nose and taste are both very similar, quite floral and fruity. The mouth of the whisky consists of a bit of barley and more fresh meadows.
A short but nice finish. Nothing in your throat, but it lingers a bit in the mouth. Do not drink this one after another whisky, because the taste is a bit fragile.
Tobermory 10:
A hard to judge whisky. Lower highlands, or almost high lowlands in the taste. A marketing guy would call it well rounded, but that would just to be to conceal the lack of expression in any direction. Nose and finish don't live up to expectations of a harbour whisky.
Fun fact: I had this a year ago, when I started tasting Scotch, and I thought Tobermory would be a long time favorite...
The Arran 10:
The next step. An Island whisky (non-Islay, of course). I bought this because I was curious how a non-finished Arran would taste. It is very fresh on the nose, almost like walking in a field during a spring rain. The taste lives up to the expectations. It is like having fresh fruits distilled. Apples, grapes and stuff like that. A bit floral as well. Almost no finish though...
Scapa 14:
Up north, to Orkney. The nose is somewhere in between anise and nuts. Still very fresh. The taste goes more towards a bit of oily anise. I recognize the taste of an Island whisky by the little bit of salty freshness. A longish finish that doesn't reveal any new tastes.
Note: I bought a litre of this, because that was the only way of getting it to fit in the 30 euro project per 0.7 litre. The normal bottle is a little bit over 30 bucks.
Laphroaig 10:
LEATHER. This is a very smooth whisky compared to the more popular Quarter Cask, but still... It smells like waxed saddles and chesterfield chairs. The smoke is not as pronounced as I expected it to be, but still very much there. A bit of wood on the tongue? Not that long a finish, but that could be because it was the fifth of the afternoon.
Fun fact: the difference in price between 0.7 and 1 litre was just € 2,50...
Smokehead:
I recon this is an Ardbeg like my liquor supplier told me, but some people say it is an Caol Ila.
This has lots of leather and peat smoke in there (as the name implies). The taste is quite salty, but I think there is a small hint of plastic in there as well. The finish is a bit longer than the Laphroaig's
Results:
In the end of the afternoon we decided to set up a top 3 and the results were not too surprising for me:
#1: Laphraoig 10
#2: Scapa 14
#3: Smokehead
The Laphroaig just beat the Scapa by one point, and that is because that is a very very good whisky as well.
In total I bought 12 bottles of whisky which were priced below 30 euros per 0.7 litres. Some remarks might be handy:
- Glen Grant 10 is considered very good for making sauces and to be used in cooking only. All of my friends that tasted it thought this was the worst whisky of the 12 ones tasted.
- Glenfiddich 12 is a bit of a soft whisky. I still have and almost full bottle, and that will not change for some time...
- Bunnahabhain 12: very very good and quite surprising for an Islay whisky. This is one that didn't make it because we didn't want more than 2 Islay whiskies in the final tasting. One that might have been a top 3 whisky if we tasted it today.
- Battlehill (Miltonduff 7): quite nice, but not one that you will remember next year. The price/quality comparison is very good though.
- Old Pulteny 12: Lost to Scapa. Quite a good one, but I would recommend Scapa over this one.
- Auld Edinburgh Islay (Bruichladdich 10): Nice, peat, smoke and still a bit fruity in the distance. A good one that didn't make it for the same reason as the Bunna. This one wouldn't have made it to top 3 though.
Will I do such a project again: No. I liked some of the whiskies, but in the end there are about 4 bottles that I would not have bought otherwise. There is some good quality in the cheaper whiskies, but as soon as you compare it to one of € 50, you know where those extra 20 bucks went. It cost me a bit too much cash, and in several cases it did not pay off.
Labels: whisky
The helicopter flew through some powerlines that were hanging over the river Waal. This caused an enormous blackout in the adjacent areas. There are 50.000 houses without electricity since Wednesday evening, which also means no heating.
I have started playing World in Conflict last week, a nice new computer game. I expect ot finish playing that game somewhere next week.
Last weekend I had the second part of my 30 euro project tastings. We had two tastings since I stopped buying more bottles, just to determine which ones we were going to drink as a closing act. The list has been completed now, and we are quite satisfied with the quality of the whiskies you can buy for 30 euros per bottle.

